You need focus and craftsmanship to build high-quality products
- It is really hard to keep things simple, especially if you have a product that people like. When you do things well, people will always ask you to do more. Your features will multiply and expand as you try to make them happy. Soon, new competitors will emerge that will tempt you to stretch your product in new directions. The more you say yes, the bigger and more complicated your product will become.
- When companies grow it becomes near impossible for leaders to be involved in every single product decision. Teams and orgs will need a way to make smaller decisions on their own. An abstraction layer will be created to give everyone a way of knowing if they are pushing their part of the product in the right direction.
- When your vision is just “let’s do more stuff,” you may find yourself discovering more and more new competitors over time. They might be in spaces that are adjacent to what you’re already doing, or in completely new verticals. Every new competitor means a new team is formed, with new goals, and usually a directive from leadership to “defeat” this new competitor at any cost.
- Small teams have a good reason to stay focused. Companies with a small, talented team and a clear vision can easily produce high-quality products with a focus on craftsmanship, since everyone is motivated to do things well. As teams and companies grow, the cost of maintaining quality and craft increases exponentially, requiring more time and energy to keep things consistent. To keep “moving fast,” it’s essential to allocate an equal number of people to focus on the foundational aspects that have brought the company to where it is now.
- Google makes the vast majority of its vast amounts of money from selling ads against the searches you make. When you search, it shows you a bunch of links, some of which show up because an advertiser paid, some of which show up because they’re the most relevant, and some of which show up because the company behind them is good at Search Engine Optimization. When you click on ad links, Google makes money.
- AI-based chat, like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, doesn’t give you links. It gives you answers. The ChatGPT answer is more useful, although it’s not 100% reliable. From Google’s perspective as a search ads business, the ChatGPT answer is terrible: there are no links.
- OpenAI, which had no business model until a few weeks ago, offers access to ChatGPT Plus for $20 a month and recently announced ChatGPT plugins. Plugins have the potential to challenge Google even more than ChatGPT itself because they both connects to the internet for real-time results and get into the valuable commerce searches – travel, shopping, food, and more – that ChatGPT hadn’t previously touched. Users may prefer a chat that takes actions on their behalf to a page full of links they need to search through themselves.
- It’s still very early in the race, but it puts Google’s search business in an uncomfortable position for the first time in 25 years, a period of near-monopoly during which the company has built tremendous advantages in search. During that period, being positioned has been all upside.
- Being deeply positioned can be excellent. If you’re in a war of position, like Google has been in search for over two decades, being positioned lets you accumulate advantages and dig deeper moats over time.
- The downsides of being positioned come in many flavors and from many directions. As with most such things, culture is one of a company’s most powerful assets right until it isn’t: the same underlying assumptions that permit an organization to scale massively constrain the ability of that same organization to change direction. More distressingly, culture prevents organizations from even knowing they need to do so.
- Risk is at the heart of positioning. When companies have more to lose, they tend to become more risk averse. It’s understandable, but companies need to realize that they’re taking a big risk by avoiding taking risks.
- As a company deepens it oosition, it builds a stronger and stronger desire to protect the core, and more and more detritus designed to do just that. It becomes risk averse. The rebels who want to build great things leave.
- Google is facing an existential threat, if not an Innovator’s Dilemma. Through its entire history, it’s built skills and structures that reinforce its ability to give the best links for any given search query, and to sell ads against those searches. It has become deeply, deeply positioned in search. This is a company that is so deeply positioned that it’s paralyzed.
- Google’s strengths have become weaknesses. It has a lot to lose, and risks losing it all by not taking risks. To survive, it will need to cut weight, take risks, and move fast. Google needs to return to its mission and shift from a search company to an information organization company.
- The good news about being positioned is that it’s actually somewhat easier to deal with than the Innovator’s Dilemma once a company acknowledges that it’s no longer in a war of position but a war of maneuver. The Innovator’s Dilemma requires companies to take a bet on external factors – whether or not there will be a market for this crappy new thing eventually – but in the case of AI, there’s no doubt about the size of the prize for the winners.
How Airbnb decided on the 50 major upgrades?
Mobilised the entire company to go through every single thing people are complaining about and try to knock them out one by one.
We haven’t fixed everything. We’re honestly kind of just getting started, but we did 50 major improvements and fixes today. And the way we did it is we actually created a blueprint of the entire experience. So I think of our company as kind of like a design-driven company in some ways, and we basically created a storyboard of the guest journeys and the host journey.
Then we took all 150 product screens on our app and our website, all 72 user policies, some of which are as many as a hundred pages long. Every interaction with customer service. We actually blueprinted everything. Then we analyzed millions of phone calls, thousands of social media posts. We talked to guests and hosts around the world, and we prioritized all the top complaints, and we tried to work them down the list one by one.
- Most people get seduced by great analogies & exciting stories. Clear thinkers don’t form their thinking via analogies. They identify the essence of the issue, in their specific context. Then, they use analogies as one of their inputs.
- Most people move too quickly to How & When to do a given task. But the task isn’t the goal. Clear thinkers have built a habit of asking themselves what are you really trying to do (WAYRTTD).
- Most people first evaluate the messenger & they don’t evaluate the message enough. The apparent superior/inferior status of the messenger clouds their thinking. Clear thinkers practice their best to evaluate the message separately from the messenger.
- When dealing with close choices, most people pick the choice that is less stressful to communicate & reject the choice that will seemingly require a tough conversation. Clear thinkers resist this bias & communicate the correct choice as kindly as possible.
- Most people think in terms of “X will happen” “Y will not happen”. They live in the jail of binary thinking. Clear thinkers see the future as probabilistic. They think in terms of approximate probability that X will/won’t happen & decide/act accordingly
- When choosing between X & Y, most people list pros & cons for X & Y and then try to decide. To think more clearly, start with principles/goals you care about. Stack rank them. Now you can decide more confidently between X, Y & any new options that emerge.
- Most people only think at the level they are currently at within the organization. While this is a fine default, clear thinkers create a habit of also thinking one level higher. They assess what might make sense at that level, to inform their thinking.
- Most people don’t understand much about why they think & feel what they think & feel. They are mere passengers on their own train of thought. Clear thinkers develop a habit of observing their own thinking, analyzing it with curiosity & adapting it accordingly.
- Most people decide what to work on solely by ROI. For decisions that matter greatly, clear thinkers consider Opportunity Cost.
- Most people’s thinking gets clouded by all sorts of noise & drama in their environment. Clear thinkers approach whatever they choose to work on with an ownership mindset. So they are more focused on the greater goal and they adopt a collaborative approach.
- Most people attach their identity to their ideas & thinking. This makes it hard for them to adapt their thinking & see reality as it is. Clear thinkers are not immune to the ego, but they are able to control it enough so they can iterate towards correctness.
- Most people love consistency. So they assume any truth they observe in the world must also apply to them. Clear thinkers know that at times you must adopt the antithesis of that truth to yourself so you can be a wiser, happier, effective person yourself.
Being strategic means that the outcomes produced by our actions are not at odds with our intentions.
Substack edition
You need focus and craftsmanship to build high-quality products
It is really hard to keep things simple, especially if you have a product that people like. When you do things well, people will always ask you to do more. Your features will multiply and expand as you try to make them happy. Soon, new competitors will emerge that will tempt you to stretch your product in new directions. The more you say yes, the bigger and more complicated your product will become.
When companies grow it becomes near impossible for leaders to be involved in every single product decision. Teams and orgs will need a way to make smaller decisions on their own. An abstraction layer will be created to give everyone a way of knowing if they are pushing their part of the product in the right direction.
When your vision is just “let’s do more stuff,” you may find yourself discovering more and more new competitors over time. They might be in spaces that are adjacent to what you’re already doing, or in completely new verticals. Every new competitor means a new team is formed, with new goals, and usually a directive from leadership to “defeat” this new competitor at any cost.
Small teams have a good reason to stay focused. Companies with a small, talented team and a clear vision can easily produce high-quality products with a focus on craftsmanship, since everyone is motivated to do things well. As teams and companies grow, the cost of maintaining quality and craft increases exponentially, requiring more time and energy to keep things consistent. To keep “moving fast,” it’s essential to allocate an equal number of people to focus on the foundational aspects that have brought the company to where it is now.
Google needs to return to its mission and shift from a search company to an information organization company.
Google makes the vast majority of its vast amounts of money from selling ads against the searches you make. When you search, it shows you a bunch of links, some of which show up because an advertiser paid, some of which show up because they’re the most relevant, and some of which show up because the company behind them is good at Search Engine Optimization. When you click on ad links, Google makes money.
AI-based chat, like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, doesn’t give you links. It gives you answers. The ChatGPT answer is more useful, although it’s not 100% reliable. From Google’s perspective as a search ads business, the ChatGPT answer is terrible: there are no links.
OpenAI, which had no business model until a few weeks ago, offers access to ChatGPT Plus for $20 a month and recently announced ChatGPT plugins. Plugins have the potential to challenge Google even more than ChatGPT itself because they both connects to the internet for real-time results and get into the valuable commerce searches – travel, shopping, food, and more – that ChatGPT hadn’t previously touched. Users may prefer a chat that takes actions on their behalf to a page full of links they need to search through themselves.
It’s still very early in the race, but it puts Google’s search business in an uncomfortable position for the first time in 25 years, a period of near-monopoly during which the company has built tremendous advantages in search. During that period, being positioned has been all upside.
Being deeply positioned can be excellent. If you’re in a war of position, like Google has been in search for over two decades, being positioned lets you accumulate advantages and dig deeper moats over time.
The downsides of being positioned come in many flavors and from many directions. As with most such things, culture is one of a company’s most powerful assets right until it isn’t: the same underlying assumptions that permit an organization to scale massively constrain the ability of that same organization to change direction. More distressingly, culture prevents organizations from even knowing they need to do so.
Risk is at the heart of positioning. When companies have more to lose, they tend to become more risk averse. It’s understandable, but companies need to realize that they’re taking a big risk by avoiding taking risks.
As a company deepens it oosition, it builds a stronger and stronger desire to protect the core, and more and more detritus designed to do just that. It becomes risk averse. The rebels who want to build great things leave.
Google is facing an existential threat, if not an Innovator’s Dilemma. Through its entire history, it’s built skills and structures that reinforce its ability to give the best links for any given search query, and to sell ads against those searches. It has become deeply, deeply positioned in search. This is a company that is so deeply positioned that it’s paralyzed.
Google’s strengths have become weaknesses. It has a lot to lose, and risks losing it all by not taking risks. To survive, it will need to cut weight, take risks, and move fast. Google needs to return to its mission and shift from a search company to an information organization company.
The good news about being positioned is that it’s actually somewhat easier to deal with than the Innovator’s Dilemma once a company acknowledges that it’s no longer in a war of position but a war of maneuver. The Innovator’s Dilemma requires companies to take a bet on external factors – whether or not there will be a market for this crappy new thing eventually – but in the case of AI, there’s no doubt about the size of the prize for the winners.
How Airbnb decided on the 50 major upgrades?
Mobilised the entire company to go through every single thing people are complaining about and try to knock them out one by one.
We haven’t fixed everything. We’re honestly kind of just getting started, but we did 50 major improvements and fixes today. And the way we did it is we actually created a blueprint of the entire experience. So I think of our company as kind of like a design-driven company in some ways, and we basically created a storyboard of the guest journeys and the host journey.
Then we took all 150 product screens on our app and our website, all 72 user policies, some of which are as many as a hundred pages long. Every interaction with customer service. We actually blueprinted everything. Then we analyzed millions of phone calls, thousands of social media posts. We talked to guests and hosts around the world, and we prioritized all the top complaints, and we tried to work them down the list one by one.
Thinking clearly
Most people get seduced by great analogies & exciting stories. Clear thinkers don’t form their thinking via analogies. They identify the essence of the issue, in their specific context. Then, they use analogies as one of their inputs.
Most people move too quickly to How & When to do a given task. But the task isn’t the goal. Clear thinkers have built a habit of asking themselves what are you really trying to do (WAYRTTD).
Most people first evaluate the messenger & they don’t evaluate the message enough. The apparent superior/inferior status of the messenger clouds their thinking. Clear thinkers practice their best to evaluate the message separately from the messenger.
When dealing with close choices, most people pick the choice that is less stressful to communicate & reject the choice that will seemingly require a tough conversation. Clear thinkers resist this bias & communicate the correct choice as kindly as possible.
Most people think in terms of “X will happen” “Y will not happen”. They live in the jail of binary thinking. Clear thinkers see the future as probabilistic. They think in terms of approximate probability that X will/won’t happen & decide/act accordingly
When choosing between X & Y, most people list pros & cons for X & Y and then try to decide. To think more clearly, start with principles/goals you care about. Stack rank them. Now you can decide more confidently between X, Y & any new options that emerge.
Most people only think at the level they are currently at within the organization. While this is a fine default, clear thinkers create a habit of also thinking one level higher. They assess what might make sense at that level, to inform their thinking.
Most people don’t understand much about why they think & feel what they think & feel. They are mere passengers on their own train of thought. Clear thinkers develop a habit of observing their own thinking, analyzing it with curiosity & adapting it accordingly.
Most people decide what to work on solely by ROI. For decisions that matter greatly, clear thinkers consider Opportunity Cost.
Most people’s thinking gets clouded by all sorts of noise & drama in their environment. Clear thinkers approach whatever they choose to work on with an ownership mindset. So they are more focused on the greater goal and they adopt a collaborative approach.
Most people attach their identity to their ideas & thinking. This makes it hard for them to adapt their thinking & see reality as it is. Clear thinkers are not immune to the ego, but they are able to control it enough so they can iterate towards correctness.
Most people love consistency. So they assume any truth they observe in the world must also apply to them. Clear thinkers know that at times you must adopt the antithesis of that truth to yourself so you can be a wiser, happier, effective person yourself.