Kevin Kelly’s (https://kk.org) thoughts on writing, technology, AI and his advice for young people On writing
Most articles and stories are improved significantly if you delete the first page of the manuscript draft. Immediately start with the action. To write about something hard to explain, write a detailed letter to a friend about why it is so hard to explain, and then remove the initial “Dear Friend” part and you’ll have a great first draft.
On technology
Our technologies are ultimately not contrary to life, but are in fact an extension of life, enabling it to develop yet more options and possibilities at a faster rate. Increasing options and possibilities is also known as progress.
The thing to remember when evaluating new technologies is we have to always ask “compared to what?.” Mercury-based dental fillings statistically caused some harm, but compared to what? Compared to cavities, they were a miracle. We tend to give existing technologies a pass from the degree of scrutiny we give new technologies. Social media can transmit false information at great range at great speed. But compared to what? Social media’s influence on elections from transmitting false information was far less than the influence of the existing medias of cable news and talk radio, where false information was rampant. Did anyone seriously suggest we should regulate what cable news hosts or call in radio listeners could say? Bullying middle schoolers on social media? Compared to what? Does it even register when compared to the bullying done in school hallways? Radicalization on YouTube? Compared to talk radio? To googling?
On AI
Despite the relentless hype, I think AI overall is underhyped. The long-term effects of AI will affect our society to a greater degree than electricity and fire, but its full effects will take centuries to play out. That means that we’ll be arguing, discussing, and wrangling with the changes brought about by AI for the next 10 decades. Because AI operates so close to our own inner self and identity, we are headed into a century-long identity crisis.
Advice for young people
My generic career advice for young people is that if at all possible, you should aim to work on something that no one has a word for. Spend your energies where we don’t have a name for what you are doing, where it takes a while to explain to your mother what it is you do. When you are ahead of language, that means you are in a spot where it is more likely you are working on things that only you can do. It also means you won’t have much competition.
Your 20s are the perfect time to do a few things that are unusual, weird, bold, risky, unexplainable, crazy, unprofitable, and looks nothing like “success.” The less this time looks like success, the better it will be as a foundation. For the rest of your life these orthogonal experiences will serve as your muse and touchstone, upon which you can build an uncommon life.
The ELI5 version of how Silicon Valley Bank crashed
- The way a bank works is that it takes deposits from people who have money, and makes loans to people who need money. The weird problem with focusing exclusively on startups in 2021 is that they had too much money. If you were the Bank of Startups, the main service that you provided to startups is that equity investors would give them a truck full of cash and they’d deposit it at your bank. But the customers didn’t need loans, in part because equity investors kept giving them trucks full of cash and in part because young tech startups tend not to have the fixed assets or recurring cash flows that make for good corporate borrowers.
- Your (Bank) customers were flush with cash, so they gave you all that cash, but they didn’t need loans so you invested all that cash in longer-dated fixed-income securities, which lost value when rates went up. But also, when rates went up, your customers all got smoked, because it turned out that they were creatures of low interest rates, and in a higher-interest-rate environment they didn’t have money anymore. So they withdrew their deposits, so you had to sell those securities at a loss to pay them back. Now you have lost money and look financially shaky, so customers get spooked and withdraw more money, so you sell more securities, so you book more losses.
- What you want, as a bank, is a certain amount of diversity among your depositors. If some depositors get spooked and take their money out, and other depositors evaluate your balance sheet and decide things are fine and keep their money in, and lots more depositors keep their money in because they simply don’t pay attention to banking news, then you have a shot at muddling through your problems. But if all of your depositors are startups with the same handful of venture capitalists on their boards, and all those venture capitalists are competing with each other to Add Value and Be Influencers and Do The Current Thing by calling all their portfolio companies to say “hey, did you hear, everyone’s taking money out of Silicon Valley Bank, you should too,” then all of your depositors will take their money out at the same time.
- If all the VCs hadn’t decided all at once to pull their money, SVB probably would not have collapsed. But it did.
- Silicon Valley Bank collapsed into Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. (FDIC) receivership on Friday, after its long-established customer base of tech startups grew worried and yanked deposits. The California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation in a statement Friday said it has taken possession of Silicon Valley Bank and appointed the FDIC as receiver, citing inadequate liquidity and insolvency.
Amazon’s $40bn advertising business
- Amazon sold close to $40bn of advertising last year (about $38 billion) - bigger than Prime, bigger than the entire global newspaper industry and probably more profitable than AWS
- The $38bn is a small percentage of Amazon’s overall $502bn 2022 revenue, but it probably had well over 50% operating margins, which would mean it brought in as much operating profit as AWS - $20-25bn, and without anything like as much capex.
- The $38bn is also more than the reported revenue for Prime, which also points to the problem with trying to calculate stand-alone profitability for this. Prime has directly attributable revenue and costs, but it’s also an important marketing tool that drives increased purchasing: the real revenue from Prime is much more than the subscription fee.
- The broader story of Amazon Ads, of course, is the ‘retail media’ gold rush: the realisation that a high-traffic website or app could be ad inventory even if you’re not a media company, that you have very relevant ‘consented’ first-party data (at the very least intent if not broader profiles) and probably purchase attribution too, that all of this now has more relative value given the push against cookies and third-party data everywhere else - and that advertising margins are a lot higher than retail margins.
- On the same note: Walmart had $2.7b of ad revenue last year (New York Times ad revenue was $523m), and Uber is at a $500m run rate. GroupM thinks the segment was 10% of US ad revenue last year. Nature finds a way.
- On a Usenet group in 1989, a thread was started to discuss which actresses were the most attractive, which eventually turned into a list of actresses and their movies, leading to the creation of the first version of the Internet Movie Database (IMDb) by a British programmer named Col Needham — who published a script that allowed users to search all the movie-related lists that were already in existence at that time.
- In 1996, Needham and his associates incorporated IMDb as its own business, with entries for over 65,000 films and a mission to capture any and all information associated with movies from across the world. (IMDb has been doing much the same as Wikipedia for five years longer than Wikipedia.) — Amazon bought IMDb in 1998 and supercharged the reach of its content.
- As of December 2022, IMDb contained pages for over 625,000 movies and over 230,000 TV series, plus reference information on podcasts, music videos, video games, trailers, original content, showtimes, and watchlists. These pages hold over 484 million pieces of data, from a lengthy movie synopsis to its exact run time. Completeness and accuracy are a source of pride for IMDb.
- The top 10 users successfully submitted 22,910,419 items last year, or nearly 5 per cent of all data items on the site. “Ines pape may” be the most prolific IMDb contributor of all time, with over 22 million total contributions, averaging nearly seven submissions per minute.
- IMDb super contributors want to make the database as exhaustive as possible. The ceaseless production of new movies, TV shows, and podcasts means their work will never be complete. Even if every title of the past were to become perfectly documented, every new piece of content pushes completion just out of reach. However, the aspiration remains to contend with everything everywhere and find meaning in that challenge.
Things DBs Don’t Do - But Should (cc: )
- Version control for schema changes: Databases are not aware of compatibility considerations between the application code and the DB schema, so they will not help you catch changes that break compatibility.
- Tenant awareness: You absolutely need to guarantee that no customer will ever see someone else’s data – this is critical, and no mistakes are allowed. Messing up this part will cost you the customer’s trust and may put the business at risk. But there is a bunch of other capabilities you will likely need.
- Democratising change events: The historical record of changes in a database is very useful information, and you can build a lot of useful applications by listening to or subscribing to change events.
- Soft deletes: Recovering the entire DB is a bit messy
- APIs: SQL is a great data language. But it is a terrible programmatic API. Why? Because it isn’t composable
- Modern Protocols: The mismatch between databases and modern engineering goes deeper than just SQL. There is a big mismatch between the protocols applications use, and the protocols databases use. And every project includes some engineering effort to work around this gap.
Substack edition
Kevin Kelly's thoughts on writing, technology, AI and his advice for young people
On writing
Most articles and stories are improved significantly if you delete the first page of the manuscript draft. Immediately start with the action.
To write about something hard to explain, write a detailed letter to a friend about why it is so hard to explain, and then remove the initial “Dear Friend” part and you’ll have a great first draft.
On technology
Our technologies are ultimately not contrary to life, but are in fact an extension of life, enabling it to develop yet more options and possibilities at a faster rate. Increasing options and possibilities is also known as progress.
The thing to remember when evaluating new technologies is we have to always ask “compared to what?.” Mercury-based dental fillings statistically caused some harm, but compared to what? Compared to cavities, they were a miracle. We tend to give existing technologies a pass from the degree of scrutiny we give new technologies. Social media can transmit false information at great range at great speed. But compared to what? Social media’s influence on elections from transmitting false information was far less than the influence of the existing medias of cable news and talk radio, where false information was rampant. Did anyone seriously suggest we should regulate what cable news hosts or call in radio listeners could say? Bullying middle schoolers on social media? Compared to what? Does it even register when compared to the bullying done in school hallways? Radicalization on YouTube? Compared to talk radio? To googling?
On AI
Despite the relentless hype, I think AI overall is underhyped. The long-term effects of AI will affect our society to a greater degree than electricity and fire, but its full effects will take centuries to play out. That means that we’ll be arguing, discussing, and wrangling with the changes brought about by AI for the next 10 decades. Because AI operates so close to our own inner self and identity, we are headed into a century-long identity crisis.
Advice for young people (20s)
My generic career advice for young people is that if at all possible, you should aim to work on something that no one has a word for. Spend your energies where we don’t have a name for what you are doing, where it takes a while to explain to your mother what it is you do. When you are ahead of language, that means you are in a spot where it is more likely you are working on things that only you can do. It also means you won’t have much competition.
Your 20s are the perfect time to do a few things that are unusual, weird, bold, risky, unexplainable, crazy, unprofitable, and looks nothing like “success.” The less this time looks like success, the better it will be as a foundation. For the rest of your life these orthogonal experiences will serve as your muse and touchstone, upon which you can build an uncommon life.
The ELI5 version of how SVB crashed
The way a bank works is that it takes deposits from people who have money, and makes loans to people who need money. The weird problem with focusing exclusively on startups in 2021 is that they had too much money. If you were the Bank of Startups, the main service that you provided to startups is that equity investors would give them a truck full of cash and they’d deposit it at your bank. But the customers didn’t need loans, in part because equity investors kept giving them trucks full of cash and in part because young tech startups tend not to have the fixed assets or recurring cash flows that make for good corporate borrowers.
Your (Bank) customers were flush with cash, so they gave you all that cash, but they didn’t need loans so you invested all that cash in longer-dated fixed-income securities, which lost value when rates went up. But also, when rates went up, your customers all got smoked, because it turned out that they were creatures of low interest rates, and in a higher-interest-rate environment they didn’t have money anymore. So they withdrew their deposits, so you had to sell those securities at a loss to pay them back. Now you have lost money and look financially shaky, so customers get spooked and withdraw more money, so you sell more securities, so you book more losses.
What you want, as a bank, is a certain amount of diversity among your depositors. If some depositors get spooked and take their money out, and other depositors evaluate your balance sheet and decide things are fine and keep their money in, and lots more depositors keep their money in because they simply don’t pay attention to banking news, then you have a shot at muddling through your problems. But if all of your depositors are startups with the same handful of venture capitalists on their boards, and all those venture capitalists are competing with each other to Add Value and Be Influencers and Do The Current Thing by calling all their portfolio companies to say “hey, did you hear, everyone’s taking money out of Silicon Valley Bank, you should too,” then all of your depositors will take their money out at the same time.
If all the VCs hadn’t decided all at once to pull their money, SVB probably would not have collapsed. But it did.
Silicon Valley Bank collapsed into Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. receivership on Friday, after its long-established customer base of tech startups grew worried and yanked deposits. The California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation in a statement Friday said it has taken possession of Silicon Valley Bank and appointed the FDIC as receiver, citing inadequate liquidity and insolvency.
Amazon’s $40bn advertising business
Amazon sold close to $40bn of advertising last year (about $38 billion) - bigger than Prime, bigger than the entire global newspaper industry and probably more profitable than AWS
The $38bn is a small percentage of Amazon’s overall $502bn 2022 revenue, but it probably had well over 50% operating margins, which would mean it brought in as much operating profit as AWS - $20-25bn, and without anything like as much capex.
The $38bn is also more than the reported revenue for Prime, which also points to the problem with trying to calculate stand-alone profitability for this. Prime has directly attributable revenue and costs, but it’s also an important marketing tool that drives increased purchasing: the real revenue from Prime is much more than the subscription fee.
The broader story of Amazon Ads, of course, is the ‘retail media’ gold rush: the realisation that a high-traffic website or app could be ad inventory even if you’re not a media company, that you have very relevant ‘consented’ first-party data (at the very least intent if not broader profiles) and probably purchase attribution too, that all of this now has more relative value given the push against cookies and third-party data everywhere else - and that advertising margins are a lot higher than retail margins.
On the same note: Walmart had $2.7b of ad revenue last year (New York Times ad revenue was $523m), and Uber is at a $500m run rate. GroupM thinks the segment was 10% of US ad revenue last year. Nature finds a way.
The Superusers Behind IMDb
On a Usenet group in 1989, a thread was started to discuss which actresses were the most attractive, which eventually turned into a list of actresses and their movies, leading to the creation of the first version of the Internet Movie Database (IMDb) by a British programmer named Col Needham — who published a script that allowed users to search all the movie-related lists that were already in existence at that time.
In 1996, Needham and his associates incorporated IMDb as its own business, with entries for over 65,000 films and a mission to capture any and all information associated with movies from across the world. (IMDb has been doing much the same as Wikipedia for five years longer than Wikipedia.) — Amazon bought IMDb in 1998 and supercharged the reach of its content.
Anyone who opens an IMDb account can submit additions and edits to the site. However, not all submissions are equal, as the site is governed by a Contributor’s Charter and 109 instructional guides on how to make submissions. Contributions are reviewed by IMDb, though the company is opaque when it comes to what exactly that process entails.
As of December 2022, IMDb contained pages for over 625,000 movies and over 230,000 TV series, plus reference information on podcasts, music videos, video games, trailers, original content, showtimes, and watchlists. These pages hold over 484 million pieces of data, from a lengthy movie synopsis to its exact run time. Completeness and accuracy are a source of pride for IMDb.
The top 10 users successfully submitted 22,910,419 items last year, or nearly 5 per cent of all data items on the site. NES PAPE MAY be the most prolific IMDb contributor of all time, with over 22 million total contributions, averaging nearly seven submissions per minute.
IMDb super contributors want to make the database as exhaustive as possible. The ceaseless production of new movies, TV shows, and podcasts means their work will never be complete. Even if every title of the past were to become perfectly documented, every new piece of content pushes completion just out of reach. However, the aspiration remains to contend with everything everywhere and find meaning in that challenge.