Sunny

← All weeks

What I’ve been reading (W6, 2023)

The ingredients that led to Adani's stock price meltdown

The ingredients that led to Adani’s stock price meltdown A recent report published by Hindenburg Research (an investing group) made Adani group lose $100 Billion; they believe the company has dubious accounting and business practices. Adani did put out a reply defending the accusations. There’s no clear winner yet, but here’s a breakdown of what caused the stock price meltdown.

High debt

  • The increasing proportion of the company’s investments is related to energy transmission/distribution and logistics (airports and ports). This required a large amount of up-front capital investments.
  • They financed many of these investments with a disproportionate dependence on debt (vs equity). The percentage of financing that Adani Enterprises raised from debt and equity is incontestable. The company funded almost all of its growth with debt through this period. Obsession with control
  • Under Indian rules, listed companies must have a free float of at least 25% of their shares; at least 25% of the shares must be in outside investors’ hands. But a lot of the public shareholders of the Adani Group companies seem to be offshore shell companies that are secretly affiliated with and perhaps controlled by Adani, which might be manipulating the stock.
  • Hindenburg alleges that Adani controls many outside public investors in Adani companies. Hype
  • The prices of Adani Group stocks and validations seem very high. Hindenburg says that the Adani companies are highly leveraged.
  • The PE ratio for the stock has gone from a modest 15 times earnings in the 2016-21 time period to 214 times earnings in the most recent two years, and the enterprise value has jumped from about 12 times EBITDA during the 2016-21 to 53 times EBITDA in the most recent two years. The surprise is that this dramatic boost in market capitalization happened at a family group built around infrastructure businesses. Investors have to wait for decades for payoffs and are often not driven by sudden changes in value assessment.
  • As of 2023, the collective value of the seven publicly traded Adani companies is $220 billion. For a brief period (start of 2023), Gautam Adani (the founder) was the second richest man in the world, based on his holdings in his group’s companies.

Sources: Control, Complexity and Politics: Deconstructing the Adani Affair!, Adani Has an Index Problem, ‘Extreme leverage’? Adani’s debt-driven expansion under scrutiny

A race for new search engine dominance started this week. Microsoft launched an AI-powered Bing search engine and Edge browser this week. It is available in preview now at Bing.com, and they believe it delivers better search, more complete answers, a new chat experience and the ability to generate content. (They call it AI copilot for the web)

Here is how the company CEO, Satya Nadella, appeared in multiple interviews following the launch to express their seriousness.

  • Search is one of the most profitable software categories on the planet Earth. The economics of search is very interesting; this is why Bing has a very small market share (3%) and is still profitable (earned $11bn of revenue last year). They see a tremendous opportunity for us to make real progress here; they need a few more new users daily.
  • Google has dominated this market by a significant margin — on Windows; Google makes more money than all of Microsoft. They want to build a dominant product in this category and have a more evenly spread search share which will help publishers get traffic from multiple sources.
  • Microsoft is willing to accept any “demonetisation” of the search business for the chance to eat into Google’s business, and they expect gross margins of search to drop forever
  • They believe very few times in history do opportunities like that show up where you suddenly can start a new race with a base where every day is incremental gross margin for you, and someone else has to play to protect it all: every user and all the gross margin.

Sources: Reinventing search with a new AI-powered Microsoft Bing and Edge, your copilot for the web, Microsoft targets Google’s search dominance with AI-powered Bing, Microsoft thinks AI can beat Google at search, Can Bing and OpenAI Challenge Google?

An overview of big tech’s involvement in generative AI Here’s how all the big tech companies (Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, and Apple) are getting involved with Generative AI.

  • Microsoft, Google, and Amazon are investing in cloud-related partnerships.
  • Microsoft, Google, Apple and Facebook are bringing AI into their products and using it to boost their productivity.
  • Microsoft invested around $10 Billion in Open AI and bringing AI capabilities into all their office, search products and Azure services
    • Teams, Excel, Powerpoint, Outlook, and Word, are all getting AI capabilities
    • Azure OpenAI to offer OpenAI as a service to developers
    • GitHub Copilot, AI to improve developer productivity
  • Google invested $300 Million in a San Francisco-based AI company, Anthropic, which is an alternative to an OpenAI competitor, introduced a ChatGPT alternative called Bard and brought AI capabilities into their products (improved search, Smart compose in Workspace)
  • Amazon’s most prominent alliance among the AI start-ups is Stability AI, which declared AWS its “preferred cloud partner” for building and training its media-generation models in November. Amazon also announced Inf2 instances, powered by AWS Inferentia2 chips, which deliver the lowest latency at the lowest cost for ML inference on Amazon EC2
  • Meta wants to bring LLMs and diffusion models into its apps for generating images, videos, avatars, and 3D assets. They will, at some point, offer generative AI capabilities of images and video for asset creation for advertisers. Mark mentioned that Meta would be deploying AI tools to help their engineers be more productive.
  • Apple didn’t speak publically about the exact plans, but they did mention that AI is their major focus when prodded and that it would affect every product in every service they have. One feature they launched recently was AI-narrated audiobooks, which could indicate some of the ways they intend to integrate AI into apps.

Sources: Big Tech companies use cloud computing arms to pursue alliances with AI groups, Big Tech and Generative AI

Fast growth is like fast food Jesper Kouthoofd of teenage engineering on building products with freedom:

We only want to make great products and when you don’t focus only on making money and have reached a certain level, everything becomes about quality. Right now, there is a certain cultural fascination with fast growth, IPOs and so on, but I want to go slow, really slow and think long-term. It takes time to do good things. You see, this cultural phenomenon of speed and growth at all costs is displayed in every startup, they all look the same, it’s like fast food: it looks good, its taste it’s consistent but then you feel horrible afterwards.

Orwell’s six rules for writing clearly and truthfully

  • Never use a metaphor, simile, or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print.
  • Never use a long word where a short one will do.
  • If it is possible to cut a word out, always cut it out.
  • Never use the passive where you can use the active.
  • Never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word, or a jargon word if you can think of an everyday English equivalent.
  • Break any of these rules sooner than say anything outright barbarous.

Published a short version here: https://twkrr.substack.com/p/what-ive-been-reading-w6-23

Substack edition

View the original post

The ingredients that led to Adani's stock price meltdown

A recent report published by Hindenburg Research (an investing group) made Adani group lose $100 Billion; they believe the company has dubious accounting and business practices. Adani did put out a reply defending the accusations.

There’s no clear winner yet, but here’s a breakdown of what caused the stock price meltdown.

High debt

  • The increasing proportion of the company’s investments is related to energy transmission/distribution and logistics (airports and ports). This required a large amount of up-front capital investments.

  • They financed many of these investments with a disproportionate dependence on debt (vs equity). The percentage of financing that Adani Enterprises raised from debt and equity is incontestable the company funded almost all of its growth with debt through this period.

Obsession with control

  • Under Indian rules, listed companies must have a free float of at least 25% of their shares; at least 25% of the shares must be in outside investors' hands. But a lot of the public shareholders of the Adani Group companies seem to be offshore shell companies that are secretly affiliated with and perhaps controlled by Adani, which might be manipulating the stock.

  • Hindenburg alleges that Adani controls many outside public investors in Adani companies.

Hype

  • The prices of Adani Group stocks and validations seem very high. Hindenburg says that the Adani companies are highly leveraged.

  • The PE ratio for the stock has gone from a modest 15 times earnings in the 2016-21 time period to 214 times earnings in the most recent two years, and the enterprise value has jumped from about 12 times EBITDA during the 2016-21 to 53 times EBITDA in the most recent two years. The surprise is that this dramatic boost in market capitalization happened at a family group built around infrastructure businesses. Investors have to wait for decades for payoffs and are often not driven by sudden changes in value assessment.

  • As of 2023, the collective value of the seven publicly traded Adani companies is $220 billion. For a brief period (start of 2023), Gautam Adani (the founder) was the second richest man in the world, based on his holdings in his group’s companies.

Sources: Control, Complexity and Politics: Deconstructing the Adani Affair!, Adani Has an Index Problem, ‘Extreme leverage’? Adani’s debt-driven expansion under scrutiny


A race for new search engine dominance started this week.

Microsoft launched an AI-powered Bing search engine and Edge browser this week. It is available in preview now at Bing.com, and they believe it delivers better search, more complete answers, a new chat experience and the ability to generate content. (They call it AI copilot for the web)

Here is how the company CEO, Satya Nadella, appeared in multiple interviews following the launch to express their seriousness.

  • Search is one of the most profitable software categories on the planet Earth. The economics of search is very interesting; this is why Bing has a very small market share (3%) and is still profitable (earned $11bn of revenue last year). They see a tremendous opportunity for them to make real progress here; they need a few more new users daily.

  • Google has dominated this market by a significant margin — on Windows; Google makes more money than all of Microsoft. They want to build a dominant product in this category and have a more evenly spread search share which will help publishers get traffic from multiple sources.

  • Microsoft is willing to accept any “demonetisation” of the search business for the chance to eat into Google’s business, and they expect gross margins of search to drop forever

  • They believe very few times in history do opportunities like that show up where you suddenly can start a new race with a base where every day is incremental gross margin for you, and someone else has to play to protect it all: every user and all the gross margin.

Sources: Reinventing search with a new AI-powered Microsoft Bing and Edge, your copilot for the web, Microsoft targets Google’s search dominance with AI-powered Bing, Microsoft thinks AI can beat Google at search, Can Bing and OpenAI Challenge Google?


An overview of big tech’s involvement in generative AI

Here’s how all the big tech companies (Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon, and Apple) are getting involved with Generative AI.

  • Microsoft, Google, and Amazon are investing in cloud-related partnerships.

  • Microsoft, Google, Apple and Facebook are bringing AI into their products and using it to boost their productivity.

  • Microsoft invested around $10 Billion in Open AI and bringing AI capabilities into all their office, search products and Azure services

    • Teams, Excel, Powerpoint, Outlook, and Word, are all getting AI capabilities

    • Azure OpenAI to offer OpenAI as a service to developers

    • GitHub Copilot, AI to improve developer productivity

  • Google invested $300 Million in a San Francisco-based AI company, Anthropic, which is an alternative to an OpenAI competitor, introduced a ChatGPT alternative called Bard and bringing AI capabilities into their products (improved search, Smart compose in Workspace)

  • Amazon’s most prominent alliance among the AI start-ups is Stability AI, which declared AWS its “preferred cloud partner” for building and training its media-generation models in November. Amazon also announced Inf2 instances, powered by AWS Inferentia2 chips, which deliver the lowest latency at the lowest cost for ML inference on Amazon EC2

  • Meta wants to bring LLMs and diffusion models into every one of its apps for generating images, videos, avatars, and 3D assets. They will, at some point offer generative AI capabilities of images and video for asset creation for advertisers. Mark mentioned that Meta would be deploying AI tools to help their engineers be more productive.

  • Apple didn’t speak publically about the exact plans, but they did mention that AI is their major focus when prodded and that it would affect every product in every service they have. One feature they launched recently was AI-narrated audiobooks, which could indicate some of the ways they intend to integrate AI into apps.

Sources: Big Tech companies use cloud computing arms to pursue alliances with AI groups, Big Tech and Generative AI

Originally on Substack